By Don Chaddock, Inside CDCR editor
Office of Public and Employee Communications
Joseph Wess Moore was a 15-year-old farm boy who joined the Union Army to fight in the Civil War. Decades later, he found himself sitting in San Quentin serving a life sentence for murder. While incarcerated, he fell in love with literature and the stories that could take him beyond the walls of the prison. Soon he put pen to paper to craft his own tales, publishing some of his writings in a small book used to promote prison reform.
In 1908, Moore’s fate turned around thanks to efforts of a military veterans group and the parole law. It was in 1909 that his prison writings were compiled to create the “Glimpse of Prison Life,” published for use by the newly created parolee-reintegration group, Society for the Friendless. He became an advocate for prison reform and provided assistance to paroled offenders but his life as a free man didn’t last long. The 62-year-old former inmate died of an apparent heart attack in 1910.
Some poetry, some essays, the 78-page booklet sheds light on life at San Quentin prison shortly after the dawn of the 20th century and gives glimpses into the life of the Civil War veteran. Moore made no effort to hide his incarceration, putting his inmate number on the cover of the book, 18759.
Farm boy turns soldier
Moore was born to a much simpler life than the one he was destined to lead. He came into the world in 1848, part of an agricultural-based Quaker community. When the Civil War broke out, he enlisted as a private in Company B, Fifth Indiana Cavalry, but later transferred to Company H, Sixth Indiana Cavalry.
“When I was a fatherless, beardless lad of 15 summers, I wanted to go to war,” Moore wrote. “When I saw … my boy chums enlist, some of whom were but a little older than myself, I determined to go also. But owing to my youth, it first became necessary for me to have my mother’s written consent. … I then walked away to join my comrades and to follow the fortunes of active service in times of war.”
He fought in the 1864 battle of Turner’s Ferry in Georgia and pushed on to the bloody battle of Atlanta. In 1865 at 17 years old, he was discharged.
He was 21 when Nancy Haines became his wife in 1869. They started a small family with two daughters but tragedy struck the military veteran. His wife passed away in 1876. He soon became the common law husband of Priscilla Horrocks Cade in 1877 in Nebraska.
Seeking to better their lot in life, the family headed west to the Golden State in 1900.
After just four months, Moore shot and killed 37-year-old Chastain Alverson in a dispute over a mining claim. After receiving death threats from Alverson, Moore said he tried to get an arrest warrant against the man but was unsuccessful.
Moore claimed the shooting was self-defense but the court didn’t buy his story and he was given a life sentence.
Learning to live inside prison walls
Moore wasn’t like the other inmates. For starters, he was much older than most being about 50 when he entered the gates of San Quentin. For the first 14 months he worked in the jute mill but declining health and injuries suffered during the war began to take a toll.
He was reassigned by Warden Aguirre to be the prison librarian and so began his love of literature. When Warden John Tompkins replaced Aguirre, things rapidly changed. The new warden summoned Moore to his office.
“He came in hobbling on two canes. Tompkins accused him of having received smuggled tobacco from a guard,” according to an account reflecting on Moore’s time in prison published in the San Francisco Daily News, June 5, 1909. Moore denied the allegations, to no avail. “Clad in dungeon clothes, he spent three days in the incorrigible cell.”
One of the prison directors, James Wilkins, overruled the warden once he caught wind of the incident. He ordered Moore released. According to Wilkins, the real issue wasn’t over tobacco but rumors that Moore was trying to smuggle out an article about prison life to a local newspaper. Having earned the displeasure of the warden, Moore was back at the jute mill for almost two more years.
Moore looked forward to the visitor he received two or three times each week. His wife, Priscilla, had relocated to San Quentin to be near her husband and took up work in guard White’s home. She often brought Moore homemade treats. Unfortunately, Priscilla fell ill and passed away in 1903. Moore was not allowed to attend the funeral.
Warden Edgar replaced Warden Tompkins. The new warden recognized Moore’s declining health so gave him a chance to recuperate.
“The sick prisoner was allowed to loaf about in the prison yard, to bask in God’s sunshine and look up into the blue vault of heaven,” the newspaper reported. “And when he had become well enough, he was put in charge of the condemned cells. This is an envied post, says Moore, for the work is light and the food the finest in the market. … Moore made many friends among the condemned men. He knew Siemsen and Dabner, the gas pipe thugs, well. As Siemsen passed to the death watch, he held out a shackled hand (to Moore) with a cheery ‘Goodbye, dad.'”
The newspaper also described some of the more positive aspects of life for the inmates.
“But there is a brighter side to San Quentin life,” he newspaper reported. “The men turn out at 6 o’clock in summer and 7 in winter. In the afternoon they are in their quarters at 10 minutes to 5, or on Sundays and holidays at a quarter to three. On the 4th of July and Christmas Day there is a minstrel show. On Sundays, ‘Dad’ Moore taught Sunday school in the morning among the younger prisoners and preached when the chaplain had finished, and picked up his fiddle at 4 o’clock and played … old tunes for the boys to dance by, playing until they were tired. He learned to fiddle in the army.”
Moore’s favorite warden was John Hoyle, also known as the reform warden.
“It was not that Hoyle let him loaf about the yard because his legs were half paralyzed, to write letters for illiterate prisoners. It was that Hoyle would go out of his way to hear a prisoner’s tale. There had been wardens who regarded the prisoners as beasts, to be thrown into dungeons on the words of stool pigeons. But big-hearted John Hoyle is not of these,” the newspaper reported.
“The sweetest acts of devotion I have ever seen in my life have been in prison,” Moore told the newspaper.
Brief taste of freedom
When he was paroled, he was outspoken in his efforts to give inmates and parolees a chance to rehabilitate.
“The Society for the Friendless will aid worthy prisoners now confined in San Quentin and Folsom, who have neither money or friends to assist them to secure parole, and will aid the needy and dependent mothers, wives and little ones of paroled and other prisoners, will look after the sick and distressed in all cases coming to our notice, no matter by whom so reported. There are, scattered throughout our State, many who suffer more than do those incarcerated, and upon whom the hand of scorn rests heavily,” according to Moore’s book, which had a few pages written by the Society.
His reform efforts raised eyebrows with the prison staff and local law enforcement. He was re-incarcerated but was paroled a second time on the promise he would leave the state and never return.
Moore, who had no family in the west, agreed to live with his brother in Indiana. With that, he bid farewell to California and boarded a train heading east. At the train station near his destination, the 62-year-old Moore collapsed and died of an apparent heart attack.
One of his poems about life in prison is republished below:
San Quentin’s Rugged Hill
by J. Wess Moore
There’s a rugged hill by Pacific’s tide, where the weeds do not grow tall;
a place of dread to the passers by, when the evening’s shadows fall.
The laugh grows mute, their voices hush, they pass with quickened tread;
this little spot on this big earth, where sleep the convict dead.
There many lives that promised fair in boyhood’s early time,
lie stranded there, poor battered hulks wrecked by the waves of crime.
Those little mounds that dot the hill and the weeds that o’er them grow,
may cover hearts both kind and true, yet none but God may know.
The hope of many a household fair and many a mother’s pride,
lies here unwept, unsought, unknown, close by Pacific’s tide.
God grant that in their life somewhere, they did some deed of love,
to balance with their errors in thy book of life above.
God bless and keep those anxious hearts in near and far-off homes,
who wait in tender, patient love, for him who never comes.
They wait to hear that familiar step, that’s now forever still,
they’re watching for the boy that lies on Quentin’s rugged hill.
And while the breakers nearer creep, and ships sail on the bay,
that mother, sister, loyal wife, will wait and watch and pray.